Jalopnik ReviewsAll of our check drives in a single handy place.

The 255 horsepower, four-cylinder 2020 BMW Z4 is a enjoyable however stress-free dear roadster. However I drove the warmer, extra highly effective 382 horsepower BMW Z4 M40i this summer time, and my emotions have been too sophisticated by the tip to have the ability to face myself.

(Full Disclosure: BMW lent me a 2020 Z4 with a full tank of fuel again in August. Sure, I’m conscious that was three months in the past. I’m busy!)

What Is It?

A automotive just like the Z4 screams sure issues about you. It screams that you’re childless, or that you’re retired. It screams that you simply in all probability did alright in life financially since one of many large sensible sells of the Z4 is that it suits a set of golf golf equipment within the trunk and it has an inside gap in stated trunk to suit longer rich-people pastime gadgets like a pair of skis.

The M-tuned model of this automotive — the one I had — is especially screamy. It was priced at $74,650 because it had all of the bells and whistles, which is as a lot as lots of people pay for respectable properties on this nation. Against this the membership of Z4 will be entered (with the smaller engine) on the low worth of $49,700.

As somebody who will get by on a blogger’s wage, driving a loaner Z4 quickly put me in a world I didn’t fairly belong. A world the place different Z4 guys would strategy to shoot the shit over all issues Z4. No fewer than a dozen such guys thought it essential to strategy me in my seven days with the automotive. They owned or had owned a Z4, they informed me. Typically that was all the data they have been attempting to convey.

They have been an agreeable bunch, however after so many such encounters with usually the identical demographic of human — usually a middle-aged white male — you start to ask your self some questions. Primarily: Is driving the Z4 price all of this consideration it attracts? And what may it say about me?

Is There A BMW Z Method?

The Z4 isn’t fairly cool sufficient to justify its price, nevertheless it makes up for it by current as a extremely polished, extremely enjoyable and extremely drivable roadster. I requested it after seeing one too many impeccable R129 Mercedes-Benz SLs round city that had lured me into believing the roadster life could be for me.

I presently can’t afford a brand new Z4 (I drive a Honda Fit) however perhaps I may afford an older Z4, just like the M Roadster. And whereas a contemporary Z4 received’t drive just like the outdated M, clearly, perhaps it might be comparable within the ways in which matter. Like how once you drive just about any Miata for the primary time, you now perceive the enchantment of all Miata. Is there such a system for the Z automobiles?

Once I drove the 2020 BMW Z4 M40i I felt that I now understood “Z4.” With the Z4, count on to get sunburns for those who don’t have the foresight to put on sunscreen. Possession will be painful because it’s exhausting to ever cease driving the Z4 with the highest down. It means an addictive exhaust crackle in Sport Plus mode, with engine revving excessive and large energy on the ideas of your toes; it additionally means stunning quiet and little exhaust sound in any respect in Consolation mode, with the revving restrained and the fuel mileage capturing up. The Z4, like most trendy sports activities automobiles, is a choose-your-own-adventure.

Can It Compete With The Porsche Boxster?

The Z4’s main power is that it might probably ship a whole lot of horsepower to its rear wheels and provide you with a kick within the ass — the M40i’s 0-to-60 mph time is 3.9 seconds — but in addition will get by simply positive as a lazy tourer. With the varied drive modes you can also make the Z4 be as pissed-off or calm as you want. Non-obligatory, for instance, are all the driver help techniques trendy BMWs can supply, like lane-keeping help, blindspot detection and parking help.

And whereas folks often examine the Z4 to the Porsche 718 Boxster, I’m not fairly certain that’s proper, because the 718 Boxster is aimed extra at individuals who fake to care about driving dynamics. Despite the fact that the Z4’s 8-speed ZF computerized is taken into account possibly the greatest automatic transmission ever, the bottom Boxster comes with a six-speed guide. The Z4, whereas nonetheless a pleasure to drive, simply doesn’t appear to be designed across the identical type of driver connection. The ZF 8-speed auto is as satisfying and ideal as they are saying, with gear shifts which might be smoother and faster than some dual-clutch transmissions.

All trendy automobiles — and particularly trendy automobiles at this worth level — have a flooring of remarkable high quality. Do you want rear-wheel-drive roadsters? You’ll in all probability just like the Z4. Whereas I didn’t get to check the Boxster and Z4 again to again within the week I had one of many automobiles, I see no hurt in pointing to the workforce at Car And Driver for their stab at a Z4 comparison with the Boxster:

Aided by its adaptive M Sport dampers, upgraded brakes, and limited-slip differential, in addition to the non-obligatory 19-inch Michelin Pilot Tremendous Sport summer time tires (18s are commonplace), the new Z4 impresses with a 148-foot cease from 70 mph and 1.02 g’s of stick across the skidpad, just about consistent with the final PDK-equipped Boxster S we examined. But, not like the Porsche, discovering the BMW’s circulation on highway is elusive. Its ultrareactive steering speaks in whispers and its rear finish breaks unfastened with abrupt throttle inputs. At a extra relaxed tempo, you’ll discover journey compliance and a quiver-free construction. The one factor spoiling your sunbathing is a good quantity of wind turbulence swirling into the cabin over your shoulder.

I don’t have a lot so as to add to what Automotive And Driver stated besides to say it might be a mistake to purchase the Z4 if driving dynamics have been your main concern. The Boxster is a greater automotive for that.

As a substitute, have fun the Z4 for what it’s; a dying artwork. It’s an internal-combustion, rear-wheel drive roadster within the basic custom, however for those who so select, it might probably rework into a snug convertible lavished in trendy conveniences. It isn’t meant for observe days, it’s for weekend journeys. The occasional press on the throttle to remind your self you’re nonetheless alive, and to remind your self that there actually is 382 horsepower beneath the hood, after which slipping again into consolation is a positive tradeoff for not being a Porsche.

You don’t really feel compelled to drive quick in a BMW Z4, even with the six-cylinder, even within the sportier modes; what you’re feeling as a substitute is the wind. Automotive And Driver is correct concerning the wind turbulence, which actively acts as its personal type of velocity limiter. It is a roadster not constructed for American interstates however for twisty backroads. Ideally within the dying days of summer time. Ideally there’s nothing on the radio. Ideally it’s simply you and the wind.

Ugh

Practically each trendy roadster — the Nissan 370Z, Jaguar F-Sort, Fiat 124 Spyder, Porsche 718 Boxster, and so forth., along with the Lamborghinis, McLarens, Ferraris, and BMW i8s of this world (I’m in all probability forgetting a number of) — suffers from at the least one deadly flaw, which is often worth. That, in flip, explains one of many elementary points of interest of the final word roadster, the Miata.

The Z4 is dear, too, even when the smaller-engined model begins at $12,000 lower than the Boxster. And whereas that $49,700 chunk of change continues to be nicely out of my worth vary, I’ll inform you what would possibly quickly be not after this evaluate: a used Z4, since they aren’t terribly uncommon and they’re desired however not as desired as a Porsche.

I may quickly be a kind of guys, sidling as much as a fellow Z4 proprietor, able to shoot the shit about all issues Z4. It is a future I by no means wished, provided that I’ve all the time opted for sensible with my automotive selections — see my Match. However in some unspecified time in the future you settle for you’re a roadster particular person and go the other way. Is that this what early-onset retirement appears to be like like?